With all the banana flavor of banana cream pudding wrapped in a cookie, these are the perfect summer treat! Filled with white chocolate chips, crushed vanilla wafers, and topped with a sweet glaze. 

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

YOU CHOOSE!

Your cookies, your way! At checkout, include a note of ANY cookies you'd like!

Note: Seasonal Cookies such as the White Peppermint Cheesecake are not available for an assortment order. 

Tastes like summer! Who knew citrus and spice complement each other so well! This soft and chewy cookie combines lemons and crystallized ginger topped with a lemon glaze to provide the perfect finishing touch! 

BRAND NEW! We've been testing and tasting and here we are! Oatmeal Scotchies! WOW! These oatmeal, butterscotch chip cookies with grated orange peels are a new favorite! And we mean "WOW!" 

These carrot cake cookies are cake-like! Made with real carrots, all the spices, pecans or walnuts (if desired), and a cream cheese center!

Our classic chocolate chip cookies but now with candy coated milk chocolate M&M’s — made with Pastel M&M's for the spring!

Made with creamy Biscoff cookie butter spread, plenty of Biscoff cookie chunks, and white chocolate chips!

There’s always a reason to celebrate and who doesn’t like cake? Make any occasion extra sweet with our decadent triple layer cookie cakes!

Specifications: You may choose a different flavor per layer, if you wish. You may also choose buttercream or cream cheese frosting. Each cake measures 6 inches in diameter and is approximately 6 inches tall.

Please make sure to note your preferences, including your pick-up date, at check out.

*Our cookie cakes are only available for pick-up currently but will become available for shipping soon!

Could this be love? A soft strawberry cookie loaded with freeze-dried strawberries, white chocolate chips, and a decadent cheesecake filling. It's time to fall in love again!

A thick and crunchy Oreo center with a soft cookie base. These cookies are chewy and sweet with big chunks of Oreos and white chocolate chips!

Give us s'more! A gooey marshmallow and chocolate center paired with a graham cracker on the bottom.

Double chocolate with creamy peanut butter filling mixed with Reese's™ peanut butter chips.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

Inspired by Genesis 9:12-17. God sent a rainbow as a reminder of the promise that He would never flood the earth again. This cookie features white chocolate chips covered in rainbow sprinkles.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

Where it all began. Our classic chocolate chip cookie.

A true classic with a chewy center, crispy edges, and packed with oats and sweet raisins.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

A snickerdoodle made with a Teaspoon of Salt and Grace and topped with cinnamon sugar.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

A soft sea salt caramel center with chocolate chips.

Packed with oats and chocolate chips, these are a beautiful take on an oldie but goodie.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

Reese's™ peanut butter chips mixed with our classic chocolate chips.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

Calling all walnut lovers! Walnuts galore paired with our classic chocolate chips.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

Inspired by Coco Gauff's 2023 Grand Slam at the U.S. Open, this cookie is filled with cocoa powder and double the chocolate for a brownie-like taste.

NEW! Gluten-Free Options Available!

FALL FLAVORS!

IT'S BACK! *LIMITED-TIME ONLY!*

A snickerdoodle with a soft caramel apple center. A seasonal offering. Enjoy while you can! 

Can you ever have enough chocolate? Our classic chocolate chip cookie paired with a generous swirl of Nutella! 

Every month, members will receive a box of cookies delivered straight to their door. Each cookie box will have a 10% discount and ship for $5!

Orders will ship the first week of every month.

Please note: You may choose a different cookie assortment, prior to shipment, if you wish, by emailing us. The flavors that you select with this order will be your default flavors for future months (unless changed).

At check out, please include which assortment of cookies you'd like in the "Order special instructions" section.

Send the gift of cookies with an e-gift card!